Working with a professional

Chimney and Solid-Fuel Obligations for Vermont Landlords: What to Establish Before a Tenancy

Renting a property with a solid-fuel appliance raises three separate questions that are frequently confused with each other. The first is whether the appliance and its flue are safe and correctly installed, which is a technical finding an inspection produces. The second is what your municipality and your rental housing rules require, which varies by town and is answered by your local code or health officer instead of by a contractor. The third is what your insurer requires, which is answered by your policy and is often stricter than either of the first two. None of these substitutes for the others. What an inspection gives you is the evidence base all three depend on: a dated record of the flue's condition, the appliance's installation and any conditions found, in a form you can hand to a code officer, an underwriter or a tenant.

Three questions that are constantly mistaken for one

A landlord asking 'do I need a chimney inspection' is commonly asking all three of these at once. They have different answers and different sources.

QuestionWho answers itWhat it turns onWhat we contribute
Is the equipment safe and correctly installed?A chimney professionalCondition, listing, clearances, flue sizeThe finding itself, in writing
What does my town require?Municipal code or health officerLocal rules, which vary and changeNothing: ask them, and get it in writing
What does my policy require?Your insurer or brokerContract terms, often stricter than codeA report in the format they accept
What must the tenant be told?You, in writingOperation, fuel, faults, who to callThe operating content to include
What happens after a chimney fire?All three, in that orderDamage assessment, then reporting, then claimThe Level 2 the situation requires

The technical question, and what settles it

Is the appliance correctly installed for its listing, is the flue intact and correctly sized for it, and are clearances to combustibles respected? Those are findings, not opinions. A Level 2 inspection with a camera scan produces them in writing. On rental stock in this county the recurring findings are a stove installed by a previous owner without regard to its listing, and a flue sized for a heating system that was replaced two conversions ago.

The regulatory question, and who owns it

Rental habitability requirements and municipal fire and building codes are set locally and change. Burlington, South Burlington, Winooski and the smaller towns do not administer them identically. A chimney contractor is not the right source for what your obligations are: your municipality's code or health officer is, and the answer is worth getting in writing. What we can tell you is the condition of the equipment, which is what any of those conversations will turn on.

The insurance question, which is often the strictest

Policies covering rental property with solid-fuel heating commonly attach their own conditions: an inspection at a stated interval, a professional installation, sometimes a specific report format. These conditions are contractual, not statutory, which means they can be stricter than any code, and a claim is when people discover which conditions they had. Reading the policy before the heating season, and booking to its interval instead of to a general rule, is the cheap version of that discovery.

Documentation and the tenant conversation

Two things reduce trouble more than anything else. A dated inspection record for each heating season, kept as a file, not a memory. And a written explanation given to the tenant covering how the appliance is operated, what fuel is appropriate, what to do if it does not draw, and who to call. Most rental solid-fuel incidents involve operation instead of equipment, and the operation half is the half nobody documents.

Chimney and Solid-Fuel Obligations for Vermont Landlords: What to Establish Before a Tenancy

Common questions about chimney and Solid-Fuel Obligations for Vermont Landlords: What to Establish Before a Tenancy

Am I required to have the chimney inspected annually on a rental?+

That depends on your municipality and your policy. We are the wrong source for both. Ask your town's code or health officer and read your policy's solid-fuel conditions. What we can do is produce the record either of them will want to see.

The tenant installed a stove without asking. What now?+

Stop its use until it has been assessed. An unpermitted, unlisted or improperly cleared installation is the situation that produces both the worst outcomes and the hardest claims. Assessment first, then the conversation about whether it stays.

Can I simply prohibit solid-fuel use instead?+

Many landlords do, and if the appliance stays in place it is worth disconnecting and capping the flue, not relying on the prohibition alone. A stove that is present and connected will eventually be lit by somebody during a power cut.

Who pays for the annual sweep, me or the tenant?+

A lease term instead of a technical matter, and both arrangements are common. What matters is that it is written down and that whoever is responsible produces a dated record, because an undocumented sweep is the same as no sweep when it counts.

What should the tenant handover cover?+

How to operate the air controls, what fuel is appropriate and what is not, what dry wood means in practice, what to do if the appliance does not draw or smoke enters the room, ash disposal, and the number to call. Written, not explained once at move-in.

Does an unused fireplace in a rental need anything?+

It needs to be capped and, ideally, sealed, because an unused open fireplace is an air leak, an animal entrance and an invitation. If it is not for use, making that physically true is better than stating it in the lease.

I have several units on one chimney stack. Is that a problem?+

It needs establishing, not assuming. Shared or cross-connected flues between units are a recurring finding in converted multi-unit buildings in this county, and it is a condition you want identified by a camera instead of by a complaint.

What records should I keep?+

Each season's inspection or sweep record with its date, any work carried out with its scope, the appliance documentation if you have it, and a copy of the written guidance given to the tenant. A folder per property, kept for the life of the tenancy and beyond.

There was a chimney fire in one of my units.+

Stop all use of that flue immediately and get a Level 2 inspection before anything else, including any repair discussion. A chimney fire is a defined trigger for that level because the damage it causes is commonly inside the flue and invisible from either end.

Does a pellet stove change any of this?+

It changes the technical detail, different venting, different service intervals, a mains supply, but not the structure of the three questions. Pellet appliances also fail differently when neglected, which makes the documented service interval more important, not less.

Can you deal with the property manager instead of me?+

Yes, and on multi-unit property that commonly works better. One point of contact, one visit coordinated across units, one report covering the whole building, not a set of separate ones that have to be reconciled later.

How far ahead should I book for a heating season?+

Summer. Coordinating access across occupied units takes longer than the work does, and by late September the calendar is full of people who left it until the first cold night. Rental work is the clearest case for booking out of season.